| Author |
Post |
|
|
|
|
I saw a commercial about a documentary that talked about bottled water vs tap water and how it is a billion dollar hoax. This got me thinking about having the students carry out tests of different bottled waters and tap waters to see if there is a difference between them. Has anyone done anything like that before? What things would they test for? Any one know of a kit of some sort? I've looked on flinn and carolina and I only see things for testing natural waters.
Thanks!
Chris
|
|
|
|
|
|
I had just read an article that relates (a bit) to what you are asking. It is on page 36 of the fall 2014 issue of the MSTA Journal. At least you could evaluate this one ion in various brands of bottled water as well as from the tap from different locations in your area.
When Nothing Is Something:
Flame-test Identification of Sodium Ion Content in Bottled Water
http://www.msta-mich.org/images/pdfs/journal/MSTA%20fall%20newsletter%20final.pdf
|
|
|
|
|
|
I looked at the article Chris referred to above. It does seem that the Na ion concentration in bottled water would be high enough to detect. However the test is like to get quantitative measures they used an Atomic Absorption Spectrometer. NOt something I would expect to be commonly available.
I am intrigued that these students did get to use AA and wonder how they got hold of this. I very much beleive that we should be exposing students to more state of the art analytical instrumentation
|
|
|
|
|
|
We have a WISP (Watershed Integrated Study Program) at my school. Students in the program test water quality every two weeks at a local stream. We use Hach kits that test dissolved oxygen, pH, total dissolved solids (TDS), alkalinity, total colliform, temperature, nitrates, and phosphates. The link below includes most of those test kits. I'd suggest writing a grant to gain access to these excellent water quality testing materials.
http://www.hach.com/populartestkits
|
|
|
|
|
|
Some states have free kits for water testing that they loan out. I know that the Illinois Indianna Sea Grant program loans water testing kits out and educates you on how to use them.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
I believe this would be a very interesting experiment because we all now believe that bottled water is safer than tap water. When It can be a completely different outcome because the bottles do have chemicals in them too.
|
|
|
|
|
|
That would be such a cool experiment! LET US HEAR THE TRUTH!! Love this experiemnt!
|
|
|
|
|
|
This would be a very interesting experiment. I have always wanted to compare this, because where I grew up we would always drink the tap water. When I moved closer to the city, everyone said not to drink the tap water, and I didn't understand. So, instead of buying a lot of water bottles I decided to buy a Brita water filter to make sure the water I was drinking was safe.
http://www.rd.com/health/wellness/rethink-what-you-drink/2/
After reading this article, I think it can make people rethink buying water bottles.
Good luck with your experiment!
|
|
|
|
|
|
As an extension to testing the quality of bottled water, it might be interesting for your students to examine the environmental implications of manufacturing, transporting, and disposing of single-use water bottles.
Mary B
|
|
|
|
|
|
I think this would be a really interesting experiment for the students to try. Many people go to the store and pay a bunch of money for bottled water, but if there really is no difference then people can save a lot of money. People also pay money for "high quality" bottled water. If there is no difference between tap water and bottled water, then there is also no difference between the different bottled waters.
|
|
|
|
|
|
I am also very interested in this topic and safe water. I am currently writing a 2 week unit plan for a group of students to test water from their homes and school and then to create a water purification system. Any ideas for water testing and water testing kits? Also, has anyone ever done anything like this? If so, I would really appreciate any pointers. Thanks!
|
|
|
|
|
|
Did you carry out the unit? How did it go?
|
|
|
|
|
|
Looking for environmental science resources for grade 9.Please help
|
|
|
|
|
|
Looking for environmental science resources for grade 9.Please help
|
|
|
|
|
|
I have not done an experiment like this, but I have seen videos were someone is testing different bottle waters with tap water. In the videos that I have seen tap water is better than bottle water. If I wanted to do an experiment similar to this topic with my future students I will ask students to bring a water bottle from home and if they don’t have a water bottle I will ask those students to bring tap water instead. Then I will ask students to test their water with a pH strip. Students will observe their pH strip to see if their water has alkaline, neutral, or if it is acidic. Students will record their answers and then as a whole group we will talk about what they observe in their water.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Hi Chris! I’m Riley Meyer, a pre-service teacher with a passion for engaging science activities like the one you’re planning. Testing bottled water versus tap water sounds like a fantastic hands-on project to spark critical thinking in students. You could test for factors like pH, dissolved solids, hardness, chlorine, and contaminants such as lead or nitrates to compare quality and safety. General water quality test kits from companies like LaMotte or Hanna Instruments should work well for this project, even if they’re marketed for natural waters. Pairing the tests with research into the branding and sourcing of bottled water could add an inquiry-based dimension to your lesson. This activity has great potential to challenge perceptions while connecting science to real-world issues!
|
|
|
|
|
|
As for me, it would be nice to measure the indicators of tap water (different areas), bottled water (different brands), wells (if any), a fish aquarium (preferably it does not use chemical additives for water, a one-time test for comparison indicators with the rest) and for example from the river. In this way, it will be possible to see the picture of water in different areas, compare them with the indicators of bottled water and present them in the form of a quality map, for example.
|
|